Chaim Perelman on Rhetoric
David Frank ()"The New Rhetoric, Judaism, and Post-Enlightenmentthought: The Cultural Origins of Perelmanian Philosophy," QuarterlyJournal of Speech ,
David Frank argues that Perelman's rhetorical approach is best understoodwhen seen through relationships between rhetoric and Talmudic habits ofargument. The Jewish concept Tsedeck (Justice) is taken as crucialto understanding Perelman's work. In Tsedeck, correct orientationsare reached by moving between the rational and the reasonable; judgmentsare made on a case-by-case basis by enactments of argumentation. In thisenvironment, pluralism holds forth without solipsism; the implications ofjuxtaposed traditions are worked out rhetorically. Community and audienceare brought to agreement t on values and justice via communication in anon-violent environment. Frank argues that this interpretation of the "NewRhetoric" places rhetorical practice in a position to redeem the radicaldangers of post-modernism. This "third way" stays a middle coursebetween naive positivism and radical skepticism. People are invited to argueabout values, with ascendant communitarianism, vi
Chaim Perelman
PERELMAN, CHAIM (–), Belgian philosopher. Perelman, who was born in Warsaw, Poland, became professor of logic and metaphysics at the Université Libre in Brussels in He was also dean of the faculty of philosophy and letters and director of the Ecoles des Sciences de l'Education. Many of his early writings dealt with mathematical logic. In later years he was especially concerned with the concept of justice and with forms of discursive reasoning other than deductive reasoning.
A full statement of his theory of argument is presented in the two-volume Traité de l'Argumentation (), published jointly with Mme. L. Olbrechts-Tyteca. Some of his other major works are De l'Arbitraire dans la Connaissance (), De la Justice (), Justice et Raison (), and Rhétorique et Philosophie (). He published numerous articles in philosophical journals. Perelman was secretary-general of the Fédération
Sources:Encyclopaedia Judaica. © The Gale Group. All Rights Reserved.
Faktaboks
Chaïm Perelman
- Født
- april , Warszawa, Polen
- Død
- januar , Bruxelles, Belgien
Chaïm Perelman var en polskfødt, belgisk retoriker og retsfilosof. Perelman var inspireret af Gottlob Freges operationelle logik, og han stillede sig det spørgsmål, om der lod sig etablere en logik for værdidommene. Kunne man finde frem til en logisk analyse af fx moralisternes, talernes, politikernes og journalisternes skrifter?
Samarbejde med Olbrechts-Tyteca
Sammen med L. Olbrechts-Tyteca () fandt han frem til, at den argumentation for menneskelige værdier, som han søgte, lå udfoldet i en glemt og fortrængt, klassisk lære: den aristoteliske retorik og topik.
Nyretorik
Resultaterne er fremlagt i hovedværket La nouvelle rhétorique: traité de l'argumentation (). Hermed blev Perelman foregangsmand for nyretorikken. Ved at betone retorikken som en argumentationslære genopretter han (imod Descartes og i modsætning til fagets degenerering til en lære om talefigurerne) det gamle bånd mellem filosofi og retorik.
Forslag til videre læsning:
- Lund, Marie; Madsen, Carsten og Roer, Hanne (red.): Retorikkens aktualitet. Grundbog i retorisk kritik. 4. udga
PERELMAN CHAÏM ()
Lœuvre de Chaïm Perelman sinscrit depuis la fin des années dans le paysage de la pensée contemporaine, avec la parution du Traité de largumentation(2 vol., P.U.F., Paris, ) quil a écrit en collaboration avec Mme Olbrechts-Tyteca. Par la réhabilitation de la rhétorique, qui retrouve le statut philosophique que Platon lui avait dénié en la cataloguant comme sophistique et manipulation des esprits, Perelman peut sans conteste compter parmi les grands novateurs de lépoque.
Fondateur de la nouvelle rhétorique, Chaïm Perelman, né à Varsovie, émigra en Belgique en et fut, jusquen , professeur de logique, de morale et de métaphysique à luniversité de Bruxelles. Outre le Traité de largumentation il publia notamment : Rhétorique et philosophie(avec L. Olbrechts-Tyteca, P.U.F., ), Justice et raison (Presses universitaires de Bruxelles, ), Droit, morale et philosophie (L.G.D.J., Paris, ), Le Champ de largumentation (P.U.B., Bruxelles, ), Logique juridique (Dalloz, Paris, ), LEmpire rhétorique (Vrin, Paris, ), Le Raisonnable et le déraisonnable en droit (L.G.D.J., Paris, ). Il dirigea la collection Le Ra
Biographies you may also like
Narendra jha biography for kids Full name of 'Narendra Modi' is Narendra Damodardas Modi. He was born on 17 September in Vadnagar, Mehsana district, Bombay State (present day Gujarat). His father's name was .
Angela morgan poet biography project According to her official biography, Angela Morgan, author, poet and journalist, was born in Washington, D.C., the daughter of Alwyn Morgan and Carol Baldwin Morgan.
Dr marie zakrzewska biography for kids Marie Elizabeth Zakrzewska (zak-SHEHF-skah) was the daughter of Ludwig Martin Zakrzewska, a German civil servant who had been dismissed from the Prussian army for being too liberal, .
Cullen roche pragmatic capitalism blog Find Cullen Roche of Pragmatic Capitalism and Seeking Alpha's articles, email address, contact information, Twitter and more.
Mendel biography cortadito Gregor Johann Mendel OSA, Grzegorz Mendel (ur. 20 lipca w Heinzendorf bei Odrau, zm. 6 stycznia w Brnie) − czeski przyrodnik, zakonnik, opat zakonu augustianów w Brnie na .
Sashie masakatsu biography of michael Visit the post for g: michael.